The units of level in the detection and discrimination test are not equal. Confusion may arise because they are both called dB HL*. However, the asterisk refers to a different reference level in both tests. This is because the discrimination test is a supraliminal test by design, while the detection test is not.
In the Phoneme Discrimination:
- A 1 kHz narrow band noise of 70 dB HL was presented in a loudness balancing task in normal hearing subjects to balance the phonemes at the 70 dB supraliminal level.
- 70 dB HL* in this test means that the phoneme is perceived as equally loud as a 70 dB HL 1 kHz NBN by the hearing population.
In the Phoneme Detection:
- All phonemes were loudness balanced at threshold level.
- 70dB HL* in this test means that the phoneme is presented 70 dB above the detection threshold level.
For more details on the balancing procedure, please find attached a publication on the construction of both tests (Govaerts et al., 2006).
Pages 93-94 describe the loudness balancing for the discrimination task. Page 102 explains the balancing of the detection test.
Was this article helpful?
That’s Great!
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry! We couldn't be helpful
Thank you for your feedback
Feedback sent
We appreciate your effort and will try to fix the article